How to Create Your Own Murder Mystery Pack with Mystery Studio

Ever wanted to create your own murder mystery game? With Mystery Studio, you can design professional-quality mystery packs that others can play and enjoy. This comprehensive guide will walk you through every step of the creation process.

What is Mystery Studio?

Mystery Studio is WhoDunItHQ's powerful pack creation tool that lets you design complete murder mystery games from scratch. Whether you're creating a mystery for friends, selling packs to the community, or building a library of unique stories, Mystery Studio provides everything you need.

What you can create:

Complete mystery packs with 4-12 characters

Multiple investigation rounds

Interactive clues and evidence

Character backstories and secrets

Custom inventory items

Getting Started

Accessing Mystery Studio

Navigate to Studio from your dashboard. You'll see options to:

Start a new pack

Load saved drafts

View your published packs

Pro tip: Start with a clear concept before opening the editor. Having your theme, setting, and basic plot outlined will make the creation process much smoother.

Step 1: Pack Details

The first step is defining your mystery's core information.

Essential Details

Title: Make it intriguing and descriptive

✅ "Murder at the Museum Gala"

✅ "Death on the Orient Express"

❌ "My Mystery" (too vague)

Tagline: A one-line hook that sells your mystery

Example: "A priceless artifact is stolen, and the curator is dead. Someone at this gala is a killer."

Description: 3-5 paragraphs explaining:

The setting and atmosphere

The inciting incident (the murder)

What makes your mystery unique

What players can expect

Player Count: Be realistic about how many characters are essential

Min players: Core characters only (typically 4-6)

Max players: Include optional characters (typically 8-12)

Visibility: Choose who can access your pack

Private: Only you can use it

Public: Submit for approval (free for everyone)

Premium: Set a price and sell to the community

Tips for Pack Details

📝 Write your description like a movie synopsis - intrigue without spoilers

🎯 Be specific about the setting - "1920s speakeasy" is better than "bar"

💡 Mention unique mechanics - "Includes auction bidding" or "Timed revelations"

⏱️ Set realistic expectations - Don't promise 4 hours if it's really 90 minutes

Step 2: Creating Characters

Characters are the heart of your mystery. Each player needs a compelling persona with secrets, motives, and personality.

Character Essentials

Name: Memorable and era-appropriate

1920s: "Vivian Darkwood", "Charles Worthington"

Modern: "Dr. Sarah Chen", "Marcus Rodriguez"

Archetype: Quick descriptor

"The Jealous Ex", "The Wealthy Benefactor", "The Corrupt Detective"

Backstory: 3-5 sentences covering:

Their history and connection to the victim

Their role in the story world

Their relevant past actions or relationships

Public Goal: What they want others to think they're doing

"Secure funding for your research project"

"Maintain your reputation as a pillar of society"

Private Goal: Their secret objective

"The victim discovered your embezzlement. You needed them silenced."

"Find out who killed your friend before the killer strikes again"

Character Design Tips

✨ Everyone should have secrets - Not just the killer. Red herrings keep everyone guessing.

🎭 Give clear motivations - Each character needs a reason they might want the victim dead

🔗 Create relationships - Characters should know and have history with each other

⚖️ Balance personalities - Mix introverts/extroverts, serious/comedic, suspicious/innocent

🎯 The killer isn't obvious - Multiple characters should seem equally suspicious

Example:

Dr. Helena Cross

Mark as Culprit

Marcus St. James

Mark as Core (Essential character even if not the killer)

Mrs. Adelaide Wright

Mark as Optional (Optional character for larger groups)

Character Creation Workflow

1. Start with the culprit - Design them first, knowing their motive and method

2. Add key witnesses - Characters who have crucial information

3. Create red herrings - Suspicious characters who aren't guilty

4. Fill out the roster - Add interesting personalities to reach your max count

5. Review connections - Ensure everyone relates to the plot meaningfully

Step 3: Designing Rounds

Rounds structure the gameplay and reveal information progressively.

Default Template Rounds

Mystery Studio provides three template rounds:

1. Introductions - Set the scene, introduce the crime

2. Example Round - Investigation and clue discovery

3. Final Vote - Accusations and reveal

You can edit, add, or remove rounds as needed.

Round Structure

Each round includes:

Title: "The Discovery", "New Evidence", "The Accusation"

Summary: 3-5 sentences setting the scene for this phase

Clues: Evidence available to all players (MAX 3 per round)

Questions: Discussion prompts (MAX 2-3 per round)

Actions: What players can do (Typically 1, max 2-3)

Too many elements overwhelm players. Keep rounds focused!

Round 1: Discovery (Template)

Purpose: Introduce the mystery and initial information

Good clues for Round 1:

Basic facts about the crime scene

Time of death or incident

Who had access

Initial suspicious details

Example clues:

"The curator was found at 8:47 PM, slumped over the Egyptian sarcophagus"

"Security cameras were disabled between 8:00-8:35 PM"

"A half-empty coffee cup sits on the desk with a bitter almond smell"

Questions to ask:

"Where were you between 8:00 and 8:45 PM?"

"What was your relationship with the victim?"

Actions players can take:

"Interview other guests about their whereabouts"

Tips for Round Design

🎬 Start strong - Round 1 should hook everyone immediately

🔍 Progressive revelation - Each round should add complexity, not confusion

🎭 Mix obvious and subtle - Some clues anyone can understand, some require thinking

🚫 Avoid info dumps - Spreading clues across rounds keeps energy high

⏰ Consider timing - Estimate 20-30 minutes per round when testing

Drag and Drop Reordering

You can drag rounds to reorder them!

Click and hold the ⋮⋮ handle

Drag to the new position

Round numbers update automatically

This makes restructuring your mystery easy during the editing process.

Step 4: Creating Inventory Items

Items are physical evidence players can examine during the game.

Types of Items

Mystery Studio supports multiple item types:

📧 Letter: Personal correspondence, threats, love notes

📄 Document: Contracts, reports, certificates

🔧 Tool: Weapons, instruments, equipment

🔑 Key: Physical keys, access cards, codes

🎫 Credential: IDs, tickets, badges

📦 Miscellaneous: Anything else

🔍 Evidence: Crime scene findings

📸 Photo: Images or pictures

🗺️ Map: Floor plans, location maps

Creating Effective Items

Item Name: Clear and specific

✅ "Threatening Letter to the Curator"

❌ "Letter"

Content: The actual text or description

For letters: Write the full letter text

For photos: Describe what's visible or provide image URL

For documents: Include relevant details

Assignment: Where does the item appear?

Character inventory: Player starts with this item

Round inventory: Revealed during a specific round

Unassigned: Available in item pool

Item Design Tips

🎯 Make items meaningful - Each should connect to the mystery or character

📝 Write in character - Letters should sound like the person who wrote them

🔍 Hide clues in details - A receipt timestamp, a signature, a specific word

⚠️ Label clearly - Players should understand what they're looking at

💡 Quality over quantity - 10 great items > 20 mediocre ones

Step 5: The Wrap-Up/Reveal

The reveal is where everything comes together. This is what the host reads when the killer is exposed.

What to Include

The culprit's identity: Who did it and why

The method: How they committed the crime

The motive: Why they had to do it

Key evidence: What should have given them away

Timeline: When and how events unfolded

Any twists: Unexpected revelations

Writing a Great Reveal

📖 Tell it like a story - Build dramatic tension even in the reveal

🎯 Reference specific clues - Remind players of evidence they saw

💡 Explain red herrings - Why innocent characters seemed suspicious

🎭 Make it satisfying - Players should feel it was solvable but not obvious

Step 6: Preview & Validation

Before publishing, use the Preview step to review everything.

Validation Checklist

The system checks for a variety of common failures.

Additional checks you should do:

📖 Read through all character descriptions for typos

🔍 Verify clues make logical sense

🎭 Check that the killer can be identified through clues

⏰ Ensure timeline is consistent

🎯 Confirm all core characters are marked correctly

Step 7: Publishing Your Pack

Once satisfied, you're ready to publish!

Visibility Options

Private Pack

Only you can access

Perfect for personal use with friends

No approval process needed

Public Free Pack

Free for all users

Requires admin approval

Your name appears as creator

Join the community creators list

Premium Pack

Set your own price

Earn revenue from sales

Requires Stripe Connect account

Subject to approval process

Getting Help & Support

Resources available:

💬 Creator Community Forum

📧 Support: info@whodunithq.com

🎥 Video tutorials (coming soon)

Final Thoughts

Creating a murder mystery pack is both challenging and rewarding. Your first pack won't be perfect - and that's okay! Every creator improves with practice.

Start simple: A straightforward 6-player mystery with clear clues

Learn from playing: Host mysteries created by others to see what works

Iterate: Update your packs based on player feedback

Have fun: If you're excited about your mystery, players will be too

The mystery community thrives on creativity and fresh ideas. Your unique perspective and storytelling can create experiences that players will remember for years.

Mystery Studio →